Moderators: cmoy     Welcome. Please log in

Registration is required to post a new topic or a reply.
User action bar

 Forum:

New Topic Reply to Topic Search Forums
-
 DIY Workshop » The SOHA - A New Hybrid Amplifier   
Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 > >> | Next Page | Prev Topic | Next Topic
AuthorPost

guitarsenal

Joined: N/A
Locale: N/A
Total Posts: N/A

Edit Message Message [#240] posted on: 12-04-2005 09:32 PM CST (US).    View Profile for guitarsenal   Send PM  to guitarsenal   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
There is a mistake in the tube pin numbering on the first drawing. Version 2 looks good.

Thanks!

I just realized that I ordered .47uf caps instead of .047uf caps for the to ground cap of the Meier crossfeed that I plan to build into this amp. I think I'll finish building the amp on Tuesday night without the crossfeed, and add that part later.

runeight



Headphone Council

Joined: Mar. 8, 2002
Locale: Austin, Texas
Total Posts: 1879

Edit Message Message [#241] posted on: 12-04-2005 10:03 PM CST (US).    View Profile for runeight   Send PM  to runeight   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
Fixed. Thanks.
guitarsenal


Headphone Council

Joined: N/A
Locale: N/A
Total Posts: N/A

Edit Message Message [#242] posted on: 12-05-2005 02:56 PM CST (US).    View Profile for guitarsenal   Send PM  to guitarsenal   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
I just received another package from Mouser!

Those CCS diodes are tiny. The cost per ounce on those things is astronomical! <smile>

More pics soon...

runeight



Headphone Council

Joined: Mar. 8, 2002
Locale: Austin, Texas
Total Posts: 1879

Edit Message Message [#243] posted on: 12-05-2005 06:12 PM CST (US).    View Profile for runeight   Send PM  to runeight   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
Yes, I just got some Friday. And noticed the same thing. Maybe the same price per ounce as gold. Maybe more. Don't burn the buggers out. <smile>
guitarsenal


Headphone Council

Joined: N/A
Locale: N/A
Total Posts: N/A

Edit Message Message [#244] posted on: 12-06-2005 02:00 PM CST (US).    View Profile for guitarsenal   Send PM  to guitarsenal   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
Should the ground in this circuit be tied to earth ground?

I'm planning to have the whole circuit powered up and making sweet music later tonight! <big grin>

runeight



Headphone Council

Joined: Mar. 8, 2002
Locale: Austin, Texas
Total Posts: 1879

Edit Message Message [#245] posted on: 12-06-2005 02:25 PM CST (US).    View Profile for runeight   Send PM  to runeight   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
You might want to try this both ways. Mains has his circuit ground floating. Batman has his tied to the power cord ground.

The second way is preferrable, assuming that it doesn't lead to any additional noise (which it did for Mains)

Just make sure that the CT on the trafo is the ground reference point.

ericj



HeadWize Fanatic

Joined: Aug. 1, 2005
Locale: Orem, UT
Total Posts: 467

Edit Message Message [#246] posted on: 12-07-2005 01:03 AM CST (US).    View Profile for ericj   Send PM  to ericj   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
Tying signal ground to earth ground can be an invitation to ground loops that you really don't need. This is why nearly all consumer A/V products in the US have two-prong power cords.

Earth ground can make a great shield, but if it's implemented in such a way that it can carry current between two potentials, then it's not really a shield.

Guitarsenal


HeadWize Fanatic

Joined: N/A
Locale: N/A
Total Posts: N/A

Edit Message Message [#247] posted on: 12-08-2005 12:13 AM CST (US).    View Profile for Guitarsenal   Send PM  to Guitarsenal   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
I finished my SOHA tonight. It has a lot of 60 cycle noise, and I think it has something to do with B+ filtering. My scope is showing noise on B+. Also, the noise is there at the same volume all the time, even with the volume control all the way down.

I'll figure it out tomorrow. At worst I'll just build another power supply.

I can tell when the music is loud enough to mask the hum that this thing is going to sound great. Can't wait to hear it cleanly!

Here are some pictures:






[Edited by Guitarsenal on 12-08-2005 at 12:13 AM.]

Guitarsenal


HeadWize Fanatic

Joined: N/A
Locale: N/A
Total Posts: N/A

Edit Message Message [#248] posted on: 12-08-2005 12:39 AM CST (US).    View Profile for Guitarsenal   Send PM  to Guitarsenal   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
The signal to noise ratio is worse with low Q cans than with high Q cans. My AKG 600 ohm cans sound pretty good. I can still hear the hum, but only when there is silence in the program material.

I think I may have damaged one of the bridge rectifiers when I wired one of the 12v rectifiers incorrectly. That might account for the higher than expected B+ that I measured before.

runeight



Headphone Council

Joined: Mar. 8, 2002
Locale: Austin, Texas
Total Posts: 1879

Edit Message Message [#249] posted on: 12-08-2005 11:49 AM CST (US).    View Profile for runeight   Send PM  to runeight   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
Very Cool.

I think you've got to do some measurements on the circuit.

Check the B+ to see if it is >55V.

Check all PS caps to make sure they are installed in the right polarity.

Check your bridges. Do you really mean a 12V bridge?

The main thing we want to be careful of are the cc diodes.

guitarsenal


Headphone Council

Joined: N/A
Locale: N/A
Total Posts: N/A

Edit Message Message [#250] posted on: 12-08-2005 12:18 PM CST (US).    View Profile for guitarsenal   Send PM  to guitarsenal   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
When I built the power supply I looked up the data sheet for the 78L12 to get the pinout, and assumed that the 79L12 would have the same pinout. Bad assumption... I toasted a 79L12, and the bridge rectifier next to the 79L12 got pretty warm too. I'm thinking that the bridge rectifier may have been damaged. I'm going to replace that rectifier when I get home from work and see if that fixes the humming.
mains_hum



HeadWize Fanatic

Joined: Aug. 19, 2003
Locale: UK
Total Posts: 591

Edit Message Message [#251] posted on: 12-08-2005 12:22 PM CST (US).    View Profile for mains_hum   Send PM  to mains_hum   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
Yup, the amp looks fine indeed.

It would help to see the underside to get an idea of the earthing and what the vol pot looks like.

Last night while checking a couple of things on the prototype for Batman, I broke the earth wire to the pot body.
Instantly I got (50Hz <wink> ) hum that exhibits itself just as you describe.
Touching the 12AU7 glass envelope makes it worse, touching a metal part of my Rio makes the hum go away, and touching the volume pot body makes the hum go away too.

I've had this sort of hum problem in the past, and the most frequent reason was the volume pot body, either needing decoupling from the case, or explicitly needing an earth back to the signal ground. The latter case being the more frequent fix.

Yes, the hum was worse with low Z headphones ( 32Ω ), and I found my high Z headphones ( 300Ω ) hid the hum quite well, but it was still there.
Fixing the broken earth wire to the pot body made the amp quiet again.

As the hum I experienced seems so similar to your description, I think we need to investigate earth wiring before suspecting components or the B+ supply.

Toasting the 79L12 will make the sound distort but the bridge probably has survived. As you now know, the pin out is different to the 78L12.
Maybe the circuit diagram ought to show the pin numbers to make this obvious ? .. lets see what Runeight thinks.
I don't think this problem will be the reason for the hum though as I found it much more difficult to induce hum around the opamp wiring compared to the pot and valve(tube), but then the opamp is running as a unity gain buffer so this is no suprise.

[Edited by mains_hum on 12-08-2005 at 12:40 PM.]

Batman



HeadWizer

Joined: May 12, 2003
Locale: Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Total Posts: 289

Edit Message Message [#252] posted on: 12-08-2005 03:31 PM CST (US).    View Profile for Batman   Send PM  to Batman   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
Yes, I toasted a regulator (or two) during the construction of the prototype but the symptom of that was distortion more than hum. Mains_hum is correct that the body of the pot wants to be connected to signal ground.

Also measure the plate voltage (pins 1 and 6) of the two halves of the valve and adjut the pot to get ~39-40V on the cathodes. My unit has some hum if the plate voltages are too high.

Look at the caps in the PSU, particularly the two caps that couple the B+ rectifier to the bipolar power supply. If these caps are in backwards you might get hum. Don't ask me how I know this <wink>

runeight



Headphone Council

Joined: Mar. 8, 2002
Locale: Austin, Texas
Total Posts: 1879

Edit Message Message [#253] posted on: 12-08-2005 04:49 PM CST (US).    View Profile for runeight   Send PM  to runeight   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
Yes, batman is making a good point. Have you adjusted the trimpots to get 40V on the plates? If your trimpots are set to maximum resistance, this could cause the hum problem all by itself.
guitarsenal


Headphone Council

Joined: N/A
Locale: N/A
Total Posts: N/A

Edit Message Message [#254] posted on: 12-08-2005 05:06 PM CST (US).    View Profile for guitarsenal   Send PM  to guitarsenal   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
I adjusted the trim posts to get exactly 40 volts on each plate. It was pretty amazing to hear the change in the sound as I did that. It turns out I had them adjusted to full B+ voltage, so I dialed it down from 70 volts to 40. Since the CCS diodes are 100 volt devices that should have been OK, right?

It really does sound like a ground loop kind of thing. I have the case grounded to the center tap on the transformer, so the pot body is grounded.

I'll do a little star grounding when I get home and see if that helps. Also, do you think I should run a ground wires to the connectors on the case that are using the case for their ground?

runeight



Headphone Council

Joined: Mar. 8, 2002
Locale: Austin, Texas
Total Posts: 1879

Edit Message Message [#255] posted on: 12-08-2005 05:51 PM CST (US).    View Profile for runeight   Send PM  to runeight   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
If you can get 40V on the plates and the cc diodes are oriented correctly, then they are probably ok. What is the B+ now?

Batman and mains are a little better at tracking down grounding problems than I am. As many pictures as you can post of the wiring will help them.

[Edited by runeight on 12-08-2005 at 05:52 PM.]

Guitarsenal


Headphone Council

Joined: N/A
Locale: N/A
Total Posts: N/A

Edit Message Message [#256] posted on: 12-08-2005 10:09 PM CST (US).    View Profile for Guitarsenal   Send PM  to Guitarsenal   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
I soldered in the optional 120 ohm resistors at the output, and now the hum is pretty much completely under control. I'll probably still try grounding and AC cable twisting later to try to eliminate the hum.

This thing sounds great! Really big sounding. Sounds very relaxed, with plenty of reserve for big snare hits or kick drum. Very well defined bass. Nice high end too.

I like it. I don't have any tube amps to compare it to, just CMOYS (which also sound great).

Thanks for coming up with such a great little project!

runeight



Headphone Council

Joined: Mar. 8, 2002
Locale: Austin, Texas
Total Posts: 1879

Edit Message Message [#257] posted on: 12-08-2005 10:38 PM CST (US).    View Profile for runeight   Send PM  to runeight   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
Very happy to hear that it sounds so good. You're welcome. But, those of us who designed this amp also appreciate your willingness to build it. <smile>

Even though the hum problem is relieved, it's probably not really solved. If you feel like it, it might still be worth some further work to track down the problem. I'm suggesting thisn only because both Batman and Mains_hum are using theirs without the 120R resistors and are not having hum problems. So we know that the amp, when working right, is free from hum.

Let us know how it sounds after a few days of listening. <smile>

Guitarsenal


Headphone Council

Joined: N/A
Locale: N/A
Total Posts: N/A

Edit Message Message [#258] posted on: 12-09-2005 10:58 AM CST (US).    View Profile for Guitarsenal   Send PM  to Guitarsenal   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
I bet I'm getting hum from the AC wires running past the tube to the power switch at the front of the case. Also, the JJ Tesla tube that I'm using might be more sensitive to that than other tubes.

I think I'll buy a few extra tubes of different types and see how the performance of the amp changes with different tubes.

And I'm going to temporarly move that power switch and it's wiring and see if that helps.

The problem with building this into a small case is that I don't have a lot of choice about where the wiring goes.

I could rectify the filiment voltage too, but that would mean more parts in the small box...

mains_hum



HeadWize Fanatic

Joined: Aug. 19, 2003
Locale: UK
Total Posts: 591

Edit Message Message [#259] posted on: 12-09-2005 11:34 AM CST (US).    View Profile for mains_hum   Send PM  to mains_hum   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
If the AC wires to the power switch are twisted and laid flat against the chassis, that should be OK.
Yes, moving the power switch and wiring will be interesting to see what happens.

The filament wires must be twisted and must sit against the chassis.
Also, they should connect to the valve base pins at right-angles when possible.

A picture of the underside would really help here.

Whatever tubes you get, ensure at least one is a NOS 12AU7 (RCA, GEC) or ECC82 (Brimar, Mullard).
You'll find they work different to the modern JJ, Ei, etc.
I don't mean for audio quality, just for setting 40V at the anode.
What you think about any differences in the sound between new tubes and NOS tubes is subjective, but still interesting to hear about all the same, so do say what you think after your tests.

guitarsenal


HeadWize Fanatic

Joined: N/A
Locale: N/A
Total Posts: N/A

Edit Message Message [#260] posted on: 12-09-2005 06:48 PM CST (US).    View Profile for guitarsenal   Send PM  to guitarsenal   |  Quote Message in Reply  |  Report SPAM!
I made all my AC wiring extra-twisty, but that had no effect on the remaining hum.

The buffer is dead quiet. There is no hum before the tube warms up.

It's either a ground loop or dirty B+. I'm heading out of town for the weekend, so I'll have to figure it out next week.

Thanks for all of your suggestions!

Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 > >> | Next Page | Prev Topic | Next Topic
New Topic Reply to Topic Search Forums
post new topic post reply post new topic
Site navigation bar
Contact Webmaster - HeadWize welcomes comments and suggestions!
(remove _nospam_ )

© Chu Moy, 2001.

HeadWize Homepage Announcements & News Library Forums Homepage Directory FAQs HeadWize Store Registration Profiles and Account Services Private Messaging View Bookmarked Topics Forums Help